A few weeks back I was at a social gathering. And, as is typical of us humans (who are tribal in nature, not just at such places), each of us were clinging onto groups that seemed familiar or accepting. Blending in was the go-to.
As we small talked our way through those clustered domiciles of comfort, one man took the audacious step of breaking away from his zone of peace and ventured into the unknown(read find a new cluster of people). I wasn’t sure whether it was by design or by accident, but all these groups seem to be within earshot of each other.
As soon the daring individual embarked on his journey of seeking his inorganic tribe, one of the group members who seem to have been asked of the person who just exited responded by saying ” Oh, he’s some advertising type “.
That quote that I unintentionally overheard got me thinking. It was just off the cuff, indifferent and reeked of stereotyping. But it did what it needed to do- purposefully provocate.
Branding and advertising shape culture, set societal norms, and redefine human aspirations. But in a world where brands chase engagement over enlightenment and virality over value, the intellectual depth of the industry has thinned. If advertising and branding are to be a force for good, we need more intellectuals—people who can elevate the discourse, challenge conventions, and make brands a beacon of progress rather than just only profit.
In an era of rapid consumption and diminishing attention spans, advertising has increasingly gravitated toward quick emotional triggers rather than thoughtful engagement. Intellectuals bring critical thinking, historical perspective, and cultural depth that can elevate advertising beyond mere persuasion to meaningful communication. This is one way of addressing the intellectual gap in advertising.
The best advertising has always been rooted in intellectualism. Some of the most powerful advertising has been shaped by people who brought deep cultural, philosophical, and psychological insights into their work. Legendary adman Bill Bernbach revolutionized advertising by focusing on human truths rather than just product features. His campaigns for Volkswagen (Think Small) were not just ads; they were intellectual commentaries on consumerism, self-perception, and mass culture.
Brands with intellectual depth can interpret cultural movements more accurately and engage with them more meaningfully. When Dove launched their “Real Beauty” campaign, it wasn’t just clever marketing—it was informed by feminist theory and body politics research, giving it staying power beyond a typical campaign. Cultural literacy can be a competitive advantage for brands. Nike‘s partnership with Colin Kaepernick demonstrated remarkable cultural literacy. Rather than simply jumping on a social justice trend, Nike’s approach reflected a sophisticated understanding of changing attitudes toward athlete activism, racial justice, and corporate citizenship. The campaign succeeded because it was grounded in cultural and historical context, not despite it.
Intellectuals can help transform advertising from simple selling to valuable social commentary. The New York Times‘ “The Truth Is Hard” campaign succeeded because it was grounded in philosophical understanding of truth, journalism, and democratic principles—not just clever copywriting. Advertising as social commentary is a potent tool.
The intellectual approach prizes truth above mere persuasion, which paradoxically can make messaging more persuasive through its authenticity. When outdoor brand REI closed its stores on Black Friday for their #OptOutside campaign, it demonstrated an intellectual understanding that sometimes principled positions against consumerism can actually strengthen a consumer brand. In the toss-up between truth seeking and persuasion, lean more towards the former.
Another powerful example is Oatly, whose entire brand philosophy is built on intellectual honesty about sustainability. Their packaging openly discusses the environmental tradeoffs of their product, the challenges of sustainable agriculture, and even questions consumption itself. This intellectual approach has helped them stand out in a crowded market not by overselling, but by refusing to oversimplify.
Truth-seeking also means confronting uncomfortable realities about how advertising shapes culture. Intellectuals understand that persuasive techniques can reinforce harmful stereotypes or destructive behaviors when used without ethical consideration.
Intellectuals can help brands tackle pressing global issues, from climate change to inequality, by framing these challenges in ways that inspire action. Ben & Jerry’s Social Justice Initiatives: Ben & Jerry’s has consistently used its platform to advocate for social justice, from Black Lives Matter to LGBTQ+ rights. Intellectuals could help the brand connect these efforts to broader historical and philosophical movements, amplifying their impact.
On a similar vein is IKEA’s Refugee Shelters: IKEA’s partnership with the UN to design shelters for refugees is a prime example of branding as a force for good. Intellectuals could help communicate the human stories behind these initiatives, fostering empathy and understanding. By addressing global challenges, brands can position themselves as leaders in the fight for a better world
The intellectual deficit is fueling short-termism. Today’s advertising ecosystem is addicted to short-term wins—clicks, impressions, and fleeting virality. But where is the long-term thinking? Where are the campaigns that shape human behavior over decades, not days? Intellectuals in branding can bring the patience and depth needed to build brands that endure.
Coca-Cola’s ‘Share a Coke’—Tapping into Psychology and Nostalgia: Coca-Cola’s Share a Coke campaign wasn’t based on gimmicks; it was rooted in deep psychological insights about personalization, nostalgia, and social connection. By simply printing people’s names on bottles, the brand made the product feel personal, leading to a surge in sales and a revived emotional connection with consumers. This wasn’t just marketing—it was a masterstroke in consumer psychology.
By empowering consumers, brands can create a more engaged and informed public. Whole Foods through its focus on Food Education, has positioned itself as a leader in healthy, sustainable eating. Intellectuals could help the brand explore the cultural and historical dimensions of food, enriching its educational efforts. When brands are educating consumers, they go beyond selling to empowering.
The future belongs to brands with depth. As brands become cultural entities, they need the intellectual horsepower to navigate complexity, ethics, and long-term impact. It’s time to move beyond just creative hacks and bring in deep thinkers who can make branding a force for good. It’s not just about selling better. It’s about thinking better.